Love the breathability/comfort of Rothy’s but don’t want to pay $150+ for flats? Here are some companies making similar knit shoes for a lot less:
For the record, I love my Rothy’s, but I also know it’s a huge investment and always like to provide you all with affordable options. I own the Steve Madden Rosy flats in camo and love them, they do run small just like Rothy’s.
1. Kelly & Katie Fonzie Flats – $34.98, Sizes 6-11, come in several colors/patterns. I bought the camo ones when they were on super sale for $14.99 and they are great! They are true to size (they are not as pointed/narrow at the tip as Rothy’s are) and have a nice memory foam type cushion on the bottom.
2. Steve Madden Rosy Flats – $89 (I’ve also seen them at Nordstrom Rack for way less, as low as $39) – Sizes 5-11, available in 3 colors/patterns. I bought a pair of these in camo and they are really cute but do run small like Rothy’s points, the Size 11 was just too small for me unfortunately. If they had a Size 12 I would have bought those!
UPDATE (Dec. 2020): The Steve Madden Rosy flats do not seem to be available online at Steve Madden anymore, and are sold out at Nordstrom Rack online. You may be able to find a pair for cheap at a Nordstrom Rack store!
3. Steve Madden “Mia Kerri Pointed Toe Flat” – These are Steve Madden’s newest version of Rothy’s dupes. They are under $40 at Nordstrom Rack, and come in a ton of colors and patterns, from Size 6 – Size 11: